Features

Providing the keys to a new state

A group of civil societies are behind a project to answer the burning questions on independence

How will elec­toral dis­tricts be de­fined in an in­de­pen­dent Cat­alo­nia? Will the coun­try need its own army? Should we leave the Eu­ro­zone? Who would be Cat­alo­nia's clos­est for­eign al­lies? What would hap­pen to the prop­erty of Cata­lan cit­i­zens in Spain? Would dri­ving li­censes still be valid? Would the coun­try have its own wel­fare state? Would Span­ish con­tinue to be a co-of­fi­cial lan­guage? Would in­fra­struc­ture im­prove? What would be the coun­try's re­la­tion­ship be with Spain? Would Cat­alo­nia com­pete in the Olympic Games?

These are some of the ques­tions an­swered by El Clauer (wwww.​elclauer.​cat), an ini­tia­tive of 14 as­so­ci­a­tions in favour of Cata­lan in­de­pen­dence. The pro­ject aims to show the vi­a­bil­ity of a Cata­lan state. El Clauer's con­clu­sions re­volve around 12 spe­cific is­sues that ad­dress the main doubts raised by the self-de­ter­mi­na­tion process.

Òmnium Cul­tural is the main or­gan­i­sa­tion be­hind the idea, which in­cludes the As­sem­blea Na­cional Cata­lana, the As­so­ciació Cata­lana de Pro­fes­sion­als, the As­so­ciació de Mu­nicipis per la In­de­pendència, the Cer­cle Català de Ne­go­cis, Ciemen, the Col·lec­tiu Emma, the Ens de la co­mu­ni­cació as­so­cia­tiva, the Fun­dació Catalunya Estat, La Fàbrica, the Plataforma per la Llen­gua, the Plataforma pro se­lec­cions es­portives cata­lanes, So­bi­ra­nia i Justícia, and So­bi­ra­nia i Progrés. All of whom are work­ing to in­clude civil so­ci­ety in this his­toric mo­ment.

The group's main aim is to re­fute the hy­pothe­ses of fear em­a­nat­ing from the Span­ish na­tion­al­ist camp. How­ever, it is also to pro­vide se­ri­ous an­swers, even when the is­sues ad­dressed have lit­tle or no sub­stance (such as the un­founded pre­dic­tion by the Span­ish min­is­ter of for­eign af­fairs, José Manuel García Mar­gallo, which con­demned an in­de­pen­dent Cat­alo­nia to an eter­nal ex­is­tence on the side­lines with no recog­ni­tion). Thus, the is­sues raised are dealt with in a man­ner that avoids pro­pa­ganda and ex­ag­ger­a­tion and puts for­ward the most ra­tio­nal and vi­able view given the cur­rent cir­cum­stances of un­cer­tainty.

The or­gan­i­sa­tions be­hind the ini­tia­tive are keen to re­mind peo­ple that the final word on the fu­ture of an in­de­pen­dent state will be de­cided in par­lia­ment and that El Clauer is not pro­vid­ing a blue­print for a con­sti­tu­tion. That, of course, does not pre­vent the ra­tio­nal de­bate and ex­plo­ration of the most im­por­tant ques­tions cur­rently on the table.

Ac­ces­si­ble to all

One of El Clauer's strongest points is that the pro­ject takes great pains over the in­for­ma­tion it uses, ex­plain­ing its ar­gu­ments in an ac­ces­si­ble way.

“It is pre­sented in a prac­ti­cal way be­cause we did not want to make grand, rhetor­i­cal ar­gu­ments, but rather re­spond to the ques­tions that real peo­ple are ask­ing,” says jour­nal­ist Francesc-Marc Álvaro, who, along with the so­ci­ol­o­gist Sal­vador Cardús, has co­or­di­nated the writ­ing and edit­ing of the texts.

El Clauer had a pos­i­tive re­cep­tion when it launched last year, and rapidly be­came a major point of ref­er­ence in the sov­er­eignty de­bate, es­pe­cially as the In­ter­net has al­lowed web users of all stripes to con­tribute to the ar­gu­ments. The pro­ject or­gan­is­ers see the pro­ject as “some­where to find the in­for­ma­tion many of us de­bate and ask about in con­ver­sa­tions in cafés, fam­ily meals or chats while wait­ing for the bus.”

Questions on sovereignty limited to a dozen issues

The questions and doubts raised by the subject of Catalan independence are numerous. Already in the clash of nationalist ideologies we have seen exaggeration and fear-mongering used for political purposes, creating a minefield in which information is distorted and twisted, when clarity and reason are needed. In order to keep the initiative more manageable and accessible, El Clauer project focuses on only 12 of the most important issues. The subjects dealt with in the project refer to: government institutions, Catalonia's relationship with the international community, rights and citizenship, public finances, companies, the welfare state, language and culture, education, infrastructure, immigration, Catalonia's relationship with Spain and sport. In all, El Clauer poses 78 individual questions.

Sign in. Sign in if you are already a verified reader. I want to become verified reader. To leave comments on the website you must be a verified reader.
Note: To leave comments on the website you must be a verified reader and accept the conditions of use.